The Carabao Cup third-round clash between Newcastle United and AFC Wimbledon provided a stark contrast between Premier League might and League One determination. Newcastle, with their star-studded squad and recent resurgence, were heavy favorites, while Wimbledon, fighting for survival in a lower division, were the underdogs.
Newcastle United’s Starting Lineup
Newcastle manager Eddie Howe opted for a rotated side, giving opportunities to fringe players and youngsters. The lineup included:
Goalkeeper: Martin Dubravka, a reliable presence between the posts.
Defense: A back four consisting of Emil Krafth, Lloyd Kelly, Tino Livramento, and Fabian Schär, providing a solid defensive line.
Midfield: A midfield trio of Sean Longstaff, Joe Willock, and Joelinton, offering a balance of experience and youth.
Attack: A front three of Elliot Anderson, Anthony Gordon, and Jacob Murphy, aiming to exploit Wimbledon’s defense.
AFC Wimbledon’s Starting Lineup
Wimbledon manager Johnnie Jackson named a strong lineup, hoping to cause an upset:
Goalkeeper: Nik Tzanev, a dependable shot-stopper.
Defense: A back four of Jack Currie, Will Nightingale, Alex Pearce, and Lee Brown, providing experience and solidity.
Midfield: A midfield trio of Ayoub Assal, Ethan Chislett, and Luke McCormick, aiming to dictate the tempo.
Attack: A front two of Kyle Hudlin and Ayoub Kaabouni, hoping to cause problems for Newcastle’s defense.
Match Highlights
The match was a tale of two halves. In the first half, Newcastle dominated possession and created numerous chances, but Wimbledon’s resolute defense and Tzanev’s heroics kept them at bay. The Magpies’ lack of clinical finishing was evident, as they failed to convert their dominance into goals.
The second half saw a more open game, with both teams creating opportunities. However, Newcastle eventually broke the deadlock. A penalty was awarded to the home side, and Fabian Schär stepped up to convert, giving Newcastle a 1-0 lead.
Wimbledon fought valiantly to equalize, but Newcastle’s defense held firm, securing a narrow 1-0 victory. The win saw Newcastle progress to the next round of the Carabao Cup, while Wimbledon’s heroic efforts were rewarded with praise from fans and pundits alike.

Player Performances
Newcastle United:
Martin Dubravka: A solid performance, although he wasn’t heavily tested.
Fabian Schär: Scored the winning penalty and was a commanding presence in defense.
Elliot Anderson: Impressed with his creativity and flair, showing glimpses of his potential.
Anthony Gordon: Worked hard but lacked the final product.
Jacob Murphy: A lively performance on the wing, causing problems for Wimbledon’s defense.
AFC Wimbledon:
Nik Tzanev: Outstanding performance, making numerous saves to keep Wimbledon in the game.
Will Nightingale: Led the defense admirably, putting in a strong shift.
Ayoub Assal: A constant threat, causing problems for Newcastle’s defense with his pace and dribbling.
Ethan Chislett: Controlled the midfield well, dictating the tempo of the game.
Kyle Hudlin: A physical presence up front, holding the ball up well and creating chances.
Post-Match Analysis
Newcastle’s victory was a testament to their squad depth and quality. Despite fielding a weakened side, they were able to dominate possession and create numerous chances. However, their lack of clinical finishing was a concern, and they will need to improve in this area if they want to challenge for major honors.
Wimbledon, on the other hand, can be proud of their performance. They defended resolutely, frustrated Newcastle, and even had chances to score. Their performance highlighted the importance of fighting spirit and organization, even against superior opponents.
Key Moments and Player Performances
Newcastle’s Dominance: The Magpies controlled the game, but their lack of cutting edge in the final third prevented a larger margin of victory.
Wimbledon’s Resilience: The Dons put in a spirited performance, defending resolutely and threatening on the counter-attack.
Nik Tzanev’s Heroics: The Wimbledon goalkeeper produced a string of impressive saves to keep his side in the game.
Fabian Schär’s Decisive Penalty: The Newcastle defender’s calm conversion from the spot proved to be the difference between the two teams.
FAQs about Newcastle United vs AFC Wimbledon
What is the significance of this match?
This match highlighted the contrast between a Premier League giant and a League One side. It showcased the beauty and unpredictability of cup competitions, where underdogs can challenge the established order.
What is the Carabao Cup?
The Carabao Cup is a domestic cup competition in English football, often referred to as the League Cup.
Why is it called the Carabao Cup?
The competition is sponsored by Carabao, a Thai energy drink company. Hence, it’s officially known as the Carabao Cup.
What is the significance of the Carabao Cup for Premier League teams?
While the Premier League is the top division in English football, the Carabao Cup offers an opportunity for clubs to win silverware and secure European qualification. It also provides a chance for fringe players and young talents to gain valuable experience.
How did Newcastle United perform in the 2023-2024 season?
Newcastle United had a strong season in the Premier League, qualifying for the Champions League. They also reached the semifinals of the Carabao Cup.
What are the ambitions of AFC Wimbledon?
AFC Wimbledon is a relatively young club with a strong community following. Their primary goal is to establish themselves in the Football League and climb the divisions.
What are the challenges faced by lower-league clubs like AFC Wimbledon?
Lower-league clubs face numerous challenges, including limited financial resources, smaller fan bases, and tougher competition. They often rely on passionate supporters and dedicated staff to overcome these obstacles.
How do cup competitions benefit lower-league clubs?
Cup competitions provide lower-league clubs with a chance to generate significant revenue from prize money and ticket sales. They also offer the opportunity to face bigger teams, which can boost their profile and attract new fans.
The Carabao Cup clash between Newcastle United and AFC Wimbledon was a fascinating encounter, showcasing the beauty and unpredictability of the cup competitions. While Newcastle progressed to the next round, Wimbledon’s valiant effort earned them respect and admiration from football fans around the world.
To read more, click here.